Certified Datasets And Trust Levels

Why this matters

As a Data Architect, you decide which datasets the business can safely build on. Clear certification and trust levels reduce risk, speed up analytics, and prevent costly rework. Real tasks you will handle:

• Define a trust taxonomy so analysts instantly know which data is safe for production dashboards.
• Set the evidence needed (tests, lineage, SLA) before a dataset gets a "Certified" badge.
• Demote or retire datasets that miss SLAs or violate contracts, without chaos.
• Guide product and BI teams to prefer certified data for critical decisions.

Concept explained simply

Certified datasets are the company-approved source of truth for a domain (like Sales Orders). Trust levels are labels that show how reliable a dataset is right now. Think of them as traffic lights for data use:

• Certified (Gold): Use for executive dashboards and decisions.
• Verified (Silver): Good quality, minor gaps; acceptable for most analytics.
• Community (Bronze): User-contributed, limited guarantees; explore with caution.
• Experimental: Early-stage or ad-hoc; do not rely on for decisions.
• Deprecated: Scheduled for removal; migrate away.

Mental model

Picture a scorecard. Each dataset earns points for ownership, documentation, tests, lineage, privacy, and SLA adherence. Higher scores unlock higher trust levels. Continuous monitoring protects the score over time.

Trust level criteria (minimum bar)

• Ownership & Stewardship: Named owner and steward; escalation path defined.
• Documentation: Business definitions, field descriptions, usage guidance, last-reviewed date.
• Lineage: Upstream sources and transformations are mapped and understandable.
• Data Quality Tests: Freshness, completeness, validity, uniqueness, referential integrity; pass rates and thresholds.
• SLA & Monitoring: Update frequency committed; alerts on breach; on-call process.
• Security & Privacy: PII classification, access controls, masking where needed.
• Change Management: Versioning, schema evolution policy, deprecation notices.
• Adoption Signals (for higher levels): Usage metrics, referenced by key dashboards or data products.

Suggested scorecard

• Ownership & Stewardship: 10%
• Documentation: 15%
• Lineage: 10%
• Data Quality Tests & Results: 30%
• SLA & Monitoring: 20%
• Security & Privacy: 10%
• Change Management: 5%

Example thresholds:

• Certified (Gold): ≥ 90% and no critical gaps.
• Verified (Silver): 75–89% and no unresolved critical gaps.
• Community (Bronze): 50–74%.
• Experimental: < 50% or temporary.

Process: How to certify a dataset

1. Nominate: Owner requests certification and agrees to SLA.
2. Pre-check: Steward verifies required artifacts exist (docs, lineage, tests).
3. Evidence capture: Record metrics (freshness, test pass rate, usage) in your catalog.
4. Review: Governance review board validates evidence and computes score.
5. Decide & Badge: Assign trust level; add visible label in the catalog and BI semantic layer.
6. Publish contract: Document SLA, schema guarantees, and change policy.
7. Monitor: Alerts on SLA/test breach; automatic flagging if sustained.
8. Re-certify: Time-bound (e.g., quarterly) or when material changes occur.

Tip: Fast-track pathway

If a dataset is already referenced by top dashboards and has proven SLOs, you can provisionally mark it Verified for 30 days while collecting additional evidence for Certified.

Worked examples

Example 1 — Sales Orders (becomes Certified)

• Ownership: Named domain owner and steward.
• Docs: Complete with field-level definitions, last reviewed last month.
• Lineage: From ERP to curated model; transformation jobs documented.
• Quality: Freshness < 30 min; completeness > 99.5%; validity checks for currency codes; unique order_id.
• SLA: Hourly; on-call rotation defined; alerts integrated.
• Security: PII masked; role-based access in place.

Score ≈ 95%. Decision: Certified (Gold). Add badge in catalog and require this dataset for revenue dashboards.

Example 2 — Marketing Leads (stays Community)

• Ownership: Defined.
• Docs: Partial, missing field-level definitions.
• Lineage: CSV uploads + CRM extract, incomplete mapping.
• Quality: Freshness variable; completeness at 92%; email validity checks exist.
• SLA: None; no on-call.
• Security: PII tagging pending.

Score ≈ 60%. Decision: Community (Bronze). Action plan: add SLA, complete docs, implement tests; reapply in 30 days.

Example 3 — Finance Actuals (demoted to Verified)

• Previously Certified; recently missed freshness SLA (48h delay vs 12h SLA) due to upstream ERP outage.
• Two consecutive breaches in a week.

Policy: Two sustained SLA breaches trigger demotion. Decision: Verified (Silver) until stability returns for 2 consecutive weeks.

Implementation playbook (for a Data Architect)

• Define trust taxonomy and scorecard; socialize with stewards and BI leads.
• Instrument datasets with tests (freshness, completeness, validity). Store results as metrics.
• Record ownership, lineage, and PII classification in your data catalog.
• Expose trust level in the semantic layer so BI tools can filter to Certified by default.
• Set automated policies: demote after N days of SLA breaches; require approver to re-promote.
• Create a re-certification calendar (e.g., quarterly) and reminders.

Common mistakes and self-check

• Mistake: Treating certification as one-time. Fix: Require re-certification and monitor SLA/tests.
• Mistake: Fuzzy criteria. Fix: Use a clear scorecard with thresholds and critical must-haves.
• Mistake: Over-certifying too early. Fix: Start with Verified; promote after evidence is sustained.
• Mistake: Ignoring PII. Fix: Mandate privacy classification before any certification.
• Mistake: Badge only in catalog. Fix: Surface trust level in BI and data products too.

Self-check:

• Can you point to the owner, steward, SLA, and latest test results for each Certified dataset?
• Do your dashboards default to Certified datasets?
• Is there an alerting path when a Certified dataset misses freshness?

Exercises

These mirror the exercises below and include solutions.

Exercise 1 — Create a certification scorecard for a Product Catalog dataset

Define the criteria, weights, thresholds for Certified/Verified/Community/Experimental, and list minimum must-haves.

Show solution

See the solution in the Exercises section. A strong answer includes ownership, docs, lineage, tests (freshness, completeness, validity, uniqueness), SLA/monitoring, privacy, change management, with weights totaling 100%, and clear thresholds (e.g., Certified ≥ 90% and no critical gaps).

Exercise 2 — Assign trust levels to four datasets

Given metrics for Orders_v2, Leads_raw, Finance_actuals, Feature_store_users, map each to a trust level and suggest actions.

Show solution

See the Exercises section. Expect Orders_v2: Certified; Leads_raw: Experimental/Community; Finance_actuals: Verified; Feature_store_users: Verified with path to Certified.

• Checklist for your environment:
  • We have a published trust taxonomy and scorecard.
  • Each Certified dataset shows owner, docs, lineage, tests, SLA, privacy tag.
  • Automated alerts and demotion rules exist.
  • BI defaults to Certified datasets.
  • Re-certification cadence is scheduled.

Mini challenge

Your top executive dashboard depends on three datasets. One repeatedly breaches freshness by 3 hours weekly. Draft a short policy snippet (3–5 lines) describing when to demote, who approves re-promotion, and what communication to send to dashboard owners.

Practical projects

• Build a certification dashboard: show trust level, last test results, SLA adherence, and usage metrics for top datasets.
• Create a reusable certification checklist template and run it on two critical datasets. Publish badges and a one-page data contract for each.
• Implement demotion automation: if freshness SLA is breached for 2 days in a row, flip trust level and notify owners.

Who this is for

• Data Architects, Analytics Engineers, and Data Stewards establishing trustworthy data layers.
• BI Leads and Product Analysts who need reliable sources of truth.

Prerequisites

• Basic data modeling knowledge (staging/curated layers).
• Understanding of data quality dimensions (freshness, completeness, validity, uniqueness).
• Familiarity with SLAs/SLOs and access control concepts.

Learning path

• Start: Data governance basics and roles (owner, steward, consumer).
• Then: Data quality testing and monitoring.
• Now: Certified datasets and trust levels (this lesson).
• Next: Data contracts, change management, and communication plans.

Next steps

• Apply the scorecard to one dataset this week.
• Add trust labels to your semantic layer and BI datasets.
• Set up alerts and a re-cert schedule.

Progress & test

The quick test below is available to everyone. If you are logged in, your progress and results will be saved automatically.